searching Indigenous Collection Change databases

Image of Publication

  • Peer Reviewed
  • Citation only


about this publication

Culture versus gender how the mainstream criminal court system is still getting it wrong

Indigenous Law Bulletin
Volume 7 Issue 26 (Sept/Oct 2011)

Abstract: On 23 October 2010, a newspaper article criticising the use of Indigenous sentencing courts for sentencing offenders of family violence appeared on the front page of The Australian. The article claimed that 'prominent Indigenous activists' believe the courts are 'too lenient and ineffective' when dealing with offences involving family violence. In making this claim the article referred to the Victorian Supreme Court of Appeal decision in R v Morgan, in which the offender (who had imprisoned and violently assaulted his 15 year old girlfriend) was released from prison due to a reduction in his sentence as a result of having participated in a Koori Court process. The article failed, however, to address the fact that the decision to reduce the offender's sentence in that particular case was made by a Court of Appeal and not by an Indigenous sentencing court.

To cite this article: Marchetti, Elena. Culture versus gender how the mainstream criminal court system is still getting it wrong [online]. Indigenous Law Bulletin, Vol. 7, No. 26, Sept/Oct 2011: 27-30. Availability: <http://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=690458678367745;res=IELIND> ISSN: 1328-5475. [cited 03 Dec 16].

Personal Author: Marchetti, Elena; Source: Indigenous Law Bulletin, Vol. 7, No. 26, Sept/Oct 2011: 27-30 Document Type: Journal Article ISSN: 1328-5475 Subject: Criminal courts; Sentences (Criminal procedure); Aboriginal Australians--Social conditions; Family violence--Prevention; Peer Reviewed: Yes Affiliation: (1) Professor of Law, University of Woolongong

Database: Indigenous Collection